[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: snmpconf PM MIB issue #7 - pmPolicyAdminStatus name



I think I raised the issue, and I do not consider this high priority. 
As far as I am concerned your proposal to leave it as is is acceptable.

dbh

Steve Waldbusser wrote:
> 
> Issue #7 suggests that the pmPolicyAdminStatus might be confused with
> ifAdminStatus and that instead we should change it to
> pmPolicyEnabledStatus.
> 
> I think that AdminStatus has become an idiom in
> SNMP MIBs for the read-write administratively desired state of
> something. I found wide use of this idiom:
> 
> rfc1473 pppIpConfigAdminStatus
> rfc1474 pppBridgeConfigAdminStatus
> rfc1604 frPVCConnectAdminStatus
> rfc1657 bgpPeerAdminStatus
> rfc1658 charPortAdminStatus
> rfc1695 atmVplAdminStatus
>         atmVclAdminStatus
>         atmVpCrossConnectAdminStatus
>         atmVcCrossConnectAdminStatus
> rfc1747 sdlcLSAdminState
> rfc2051 appcCntrlAdminStat
>         appcTpAdminStatus
> rfc2108 rptrPortAdminStatus
> etc...
> 
> (www.mibcentral.com has a search facility that's helpful for this
> search)
> 
> I think we should stick with the current name.
> 
> Steve

-- 
---
David Harrington            Network Management Standards Architect
dbh@enterasys.com           Office of the CTO
+1 603 337 2614 - voice     Enterasys Networks
+1 603 332 1524 - fax       Rochester NH, USA