[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Proposal cutoff deadline September 15
At 03:22 PM 9/13/2002 -0400, Glenn Waters wrote:
>Not that a reminder is necessary, but proposals are due by Monday.
We are not just being asked to pick a solution, but rather a
problem and a solution. These 3 drafts address different problems.
I would like to see the WG focus on solution (2), but
incorporate the concepts of (1) into the new PDU format.
I would like to see the problem addressed by (3) solved
with general mechanisms in the protocol, without the
requirement of any pre-configuration by an application.
>The three proposals currently on the table are:
>1. Dave Shield's Extended Capability Negotiation
>2. Wes Hardaker's Object Oriented PDUs for SNMP
> (soon to be -01)
>3. Glenn Mansfield Keeni's Managed Object / Aggregation MIB modules
>The WG needs to come to consensus on path forward from here.
>I propose that we select one of the three solutions listed above as the one solution that the WG will focus on for development.
>The question that I plan on asking on Monday is:
>Which of proposals 1, 2, or 3 do you think that the WG should pursue to focus in on the work items in the charter?
>Is there any discussion around the question?